I Prayed have prayed
Father, as the Supreme Court once again considers abortion, we pray the justices would be submissive to You and Your Word.
Reading Time: 3 minutes

In July 2022, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) issued guidance to hospitals to the effect that they must provide an abortion whenever abortion is the stabilizing treatment necessary to resolve an emergency medical condition. The guidance explicitly preempted any state law forbidding abortion.

Join others crying out to the Lord day and night.

 

Today, U.S. Supreme Court justices heard, with some skepticism, the attempt of the U.S. solicitor general (herein called “the General”) to defend this new take on the decades-old Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA). The case is Idaho v. United States, because Idaho’s law forbidding abortion except to save the life of the mother appears in conflict with the more permissive HHS guidance. A similar case initiated by the state of Texas could be impacted.

Here are highlights of the arguments, which lasted over an hour and a half.

  1. The more liberal justices, such as Kagan and Sotomayor, exhibited acute concern for patients who might, due to Idaho’s law, miss out on treatment, resulting in “tragic” loss of “reproductive” organs, such as in hysterectomies and “scarring” (apparently not finding such losses tragic if they happen to minors upon the secret advice of school counselors or Planned Parenthood staff who “help” kids transition to another sex).
  2. Justice Alito noted EMTALA’s use of the words “unborn child,” reminding us of our duty to two patients in the scenario, not just the mother.
  3. The General assured the court that Idaho doctors have conscience protection that would allow them not to participate in abortions. However, when pressed, she admitted that the hospital would have to provide staffing at all times for abortion or it would be “out of compliance” with federal funding laws such as with Medicare.
  4. Justices Thomas and Alito questioned whether there was any precedent that allowed an agreement between a private entity (such as a hospital) and the government (such as with Medicare funding) to defeat state law. They seemed unsatisfied with the General’s efforts to find parallels, also indicating that the guidance improperly intrudes on the practice of medicine.
  5. Idaho argued that there really isn’t much daylight between its law and the guidance, since it does allow a pregnant patient to have an abortion where her life is jeopardized without one. Justices Gorsuch and Kavanaugh said the U.S. was overstating the number of situations in which abortion would be forbidden under Idaho law. For example, in cases of ectopic pregnancy or pre-eclampsia, Idaho would permit an abortion.
  6. When questioned about whether “mental health” would be protected under the guidance, the General said no, which is an important concession if the guidance is allowed to stand.
  7. Justice Barrett asked whether, under a different “administration,” abortion could be outlawed by a future HHS guidance. (This undesirable whipsaw effect happens when one administration acts very expansively and the next one acts to correct that.) The General reluctantly said yes, if the regulation was otherwise valid.
  8. Some justices expressed hesitance to find an enumerated power in the spending clause to interfere with states’ sovereignty in matters of health and the practice of medicine. This may sound technical, but it could dispose of the whole case.

Not only is the case crucial to the scenarios discussed, but if the federal government wins, EMTALA could well dictate what happens with an unconscious patient coming into the emergency room — she could be given an abortion whether she actually wants it or not. There are still women who will sacrifice their lives for their children, such as an OB-GYN doctor in Oklahoma who decided to forego the lifesaving chemo she herself needed because it would endanger her child in utero.

Prayers are needed that the court would wisely weigh these arguments involving federal versus state powers and the best interests of mothers and babies.

Share your prayers here for the Supreme Court as it decides on yet another critical abortion case.

Leah Farish, an attorney, is host of the Conversation Balloons podcast, available without app or subscription on Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music, and YouTube, and at LeahFarish.com. Leah is also author of “You Shall Not Murder — Crying Out for the Outcast,” in The Decalogue Project. Photo Credit: Adam Szuscik on Unsplash.

Comments (7) Print

Comments

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Anonymous
April 28, 2024

I will pray for you.

1
Ljw
April 26, 2024

It is clear to me the federal government has over stepped its authority. Our federal government has been taking powers it does not have. I believe it should first protect the USA from foreign invaders, current administration grade is F-. They seem determined to destroy the USA which I believe makes them guilty of treason. Second deal with other countries so as to maintain peace this administration grade is F spending billions to fund wars with no plan to ending them. Third settle disputes between the states not to dictate to the states this administration grade is F it is constantly interfering with state rights to govern themselves. Let us not forget how prosecutors are going after this administration political opponents which I believe to be treasonous acts. O God in your name I humbly ask that You take care of these problems. Amen

5
Missy Dice
April 25, 2024

“Blessed be Abram by GOD MOST HIGH, Creator of Heaven and earth. And blessed be GOD MOST HIGH, Who delivered your enemies into your hand.” (Gen. 14) As Dutch Sheets touched on today…. and pointed out to celebrate the Greatest Victory in history…God references Himself as “Possessor of heaven and earth” twice. God pointed out that satan failed in heaven and has done so on earth: JESUS – I AM – redeemed us from the curse. Thank You, Jesus, for bearing our curse. He is the Bread of Life. His Blood cleanses us of sin and makes us new creations. satan and his forces are forever defeated. This issue/sin with abortion, the Supreme Court and our President are all covered by the Blood. Father, direct and move hearts to value what You value, obviously that is LIFE because Your desire is that NONE be lost. Thank You Jesus for coming to seek and to save the lost. Please forgive our sins. And help us in our time of need. All for Your Glory, Father. May Your Will be done on earth as it is in Heaven. Amen.

4
Darlene Estlow
April 25, 2024

Father, I pray for our Supreme Court to have wisdom and desire to honor you and life. Guide them as they hear the arguments.

15
Mari Williams
April 25, 2024

Men who wince in pain because of a sprained ankle, or a torn ligament, should not be allowed to discuss this matter of life and death to an innocent baby in its mother’s womb.
All should be aware that GOD is watching and if they choose the heinous murder of the innocent, then they can expect HIS JUDGMENT on their own lives and the agony of death they vote for the innocent baby may one day be their own experience
There is nothing like the fear of GOD and the expectation of retribution for the murder of the innocent to make these men think twice before they blithely advocate abortion.

9
Peg B
April 25, 2024

Thank You LORD for the wisdom You impart on our Supreme Court Justices, it is evident by the questions they ask and the words they impart, who truly serves You. Let no deceit and trickery of words prevail in this case. We thank You for the gift of life, we thank You that You are the Giver of it. Please bless the justices who stand on Your word and Your will, continue to guide their paths Draw both unsaved attorneys and justices to Yourself that they too might receive the gift of salvation. Let the laws of this nation be the words of Your will. In Jesus’ mighty name. Amen.

12
Michael Briney
April 25, 2024

The Christians in this nation need to pray that our President quit acting like a dictator who has no respect for the wishes of Almighty God and take responsibility for leading this nation in a Godly direction.

18

Partner with Us

Intercessors for America is the trusted resource for millions of people across the United States committed to praying for our nation. If you have benefited from IFA's resources and community, please consider joining us as a monthly support partner. As a 501(c)3 organization, it's through your support that all this possible.

Dave Kubal
IFA President
Become a Monthly Partner

Share

Click below to share this with others

Log in to Join the Conversation

Log in to your IFA account to start a discussion, comment, pray, and interact with our community.